//
post
Nature

Nature as the site of hermeneutical play

Metaphors can be playful, and observers of nature commonly refer to metaphors of play: “we find talk of the play of light, the play of the waves,” and “the play of gnats” (104). This is a passing reference to play in nature by the hermeneutical philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer as he affirmed the importance and ubiquity of play. He is keen to point out that play is not really under the control of the players. It is as if we players are played by the game. Play plays us, as it were.

CorsicaWater2

Play is not only in nature. He extends his examples to “the play of gears or parts of machinery, the play of limbs, the play of forces.” He then adds, “The movement backwards and forwards is obviously so central to the definition of play that it makes no difference who or what performs this movement” (104), as if to say the players are played by the game.

For Gadamer play provides a metaphor for understanding the process of interpretation. He is keen to point out that’s not the same as saying play is just a metaphor. To assert that something is a metaphor does not diminish its authority as a description of the way things really are.

A few paragraphs further on in this section on play, Gadamer asserts that there’s really no difference whether we are speaking literally or in terms of metaphor.

“The fact that the mode of being of play is so close to the mobile form of nature permits us to draw an important methodological conclusion. It is obviously not correct to say that animals too play, nor is it correct to say that, metaphorically speaking, water and light play as well. Rather, on the contrary, we can say that man too plays. His playing too is a natural process. The meaning of his play too, precisely because — and insofar as — he is part of nature, is a pure self-presentation. Thus in this sphere it becomes finally meaningless to distinguish between literal and metaphorical usage” (105).

Play and nature share the same “mode of being.” So play really is everywhere. Play is something we get caught up in, all the more evident when “the player loses himself in play” (103).

I think there are many lessons here not only about interpretation, meaning, nature, agency and the character of game play, in terms of repetition, levels, progression, realism, sociability, ethics and meta-game play. I elaborated on these themes in Cornucopia Limited, and summarised them in a blog post: Game noir.

It is convenient that the words nature and play are so ambiguous, i.e. they are so amenable to word play. Play is not just a metaphor for understanding nature, but nature is in play, it is natural to play, and that is the nature of play … ideas worth playing around with.

Olympic torch

Reference

  • Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 2004. Truth and Method. Trans. Joel Weinsheimer, and Donald G. Marshall. New York: Continuum. Second, revised edition. Originally published in German in 1960.

Note

  • First image is a beach in Corsica, the second is the olympic cauldron at the London 2012 Olympics.

About Richard Coyne

The cultural, social and spatial implications of computers and pervasive digital media spark my interest ... enjoy architecture, writing, designing, philosophy, coding and media mashups.

Discussion

5 thoughts on “Nature as the site of hermeneutical play

  1. I would add that “play” is the term that musicians use, instead of work, i.e. the interplay of sound and musical communication. As both a gardener and a musician, I find enormous similarities between playing music and “playing” garden/nature – non-linguistic interactive fun that share many of the same elements and processes.

    Posted by composerinthegarden | August 14, 2016, 10:51 pm
    • Thanks for comments Lynn. Yes, of course, “play” is used in music, and people go outside to play, and play in the garden. I wonder if a gardener “plays” with hedge clippers, rakes and stake ties. She might buzz about of course …

      Posted by Richard Coyne | August 23, 2016, 8:00 pm
  2. As a graphic designer, we often respond to outside suggestions with, “let me play with your idea, and we’ll see how it goes.” Some graphic designers have an aversion to the coupling “play” with design, for fear of people thinking that we aren’t doing serious work (like finance or sales), instead we play with crayons all day.

    However, I welcome play as a large component of design. Designwork is a dance between the design, the project needs, and creativity of visual communication. A designer can try to wrangle total control over this dance, but that often ends up too forced. Instead the designer oftentimes have to let the other parts of the design guide us–which includes letting the client requests to guide us. This form of play can often lead us into great results. Or sometimes it’s just play for the sake of play, and no real results are generated by the suggestions. It’s all something we have to submit to.

    Posted by Matt Maldre | August 31, 2016, 4:44 am
    • Hi Matt, That all makes sense. Yes, when does play end? I guess there is a difference between play that is open ended and without apparent purpose (kids playing with saucepan lids) versus playing with lego blocks with the end that something gets made … or demolished.

      Posted by Richard Coyne | September 5, 2016, 2:51 pm
  3. This is great Richard. I was writing my thesis on “Playschool” and what you mentioned in your piece correlates a lot with my own observations with children at play and my own experience with play.

    Posted by Robin | September 6, 2016, 12:32 pm

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

University of Edinburgh logo

Richard on Facebook


Or "like" my Facebook
page for blog updates.

Try a one year research degree

Wooden specimens of Platonic solids in the background

AHRC/EPSRC/ESRC/MRC project

book cover
book cover

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 283 other followers

Site traffic

  • 157,422 page views

%d bloggers like this: